Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek slammed for Labor’s failure to deliver lower energy prices

Nov 21, 2022
Tanya Plibersek slammed by Natalie Barr over failure to deliver crucial election promise. Source: Getty

Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek has faced the heat over the Labor government’s failure to deliver an efficient plan to lower rising energy prices amidst the cost of living crisis.

Appearing alongside former deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce on Sunrise, Plibersek was slammed by host Natalie Barr for the Albanese government’s negligence of their crucial election promise.

“Look Tanya, it’s the six-month anniversary of your government being in and there comes a time when we can’t just sit here and blame the government before,” Barr said.

Plibersek tried to interject: “You’re judging six months versus nine years.”

Barr continued:”Fair enough, you’ve had a chance to blame the former government but doesn’t there come a time where we say, ‘this is what we are going to do?’

“You promised a plan to bring down energy prices, will you have that by the end of the year like you promised?,” she asked.

While Plibersek didn’t give a direct yes or no in response, she defended her government, outlining how they were working towards more affordable power bills for Aussies.

“We are working very hard with the gas companies and state and territory governments to do exactly that, to bring down the price of energy,” Plibersek said.

“We have really got to focus on gas in the short term but in the longer term we know with the plan is, it’s to get cheaper, cleaner, renewable energy into the grid.

“We have $20 billion set aside to update our transmission networks, on a target of 82 per cent renewable energy because we know that is the cheapest form of electricity in the human history.”

Despite bringing the heat herself, Barr was forced to interject and end the segment when Joyce and Plibersek began trading blows over renewable energy.

“Look at your power bill! That is the reality of it,” Joyce said.

“In June the grid almost fell over. If you want power prices to go down, don’t listen to the Labor party, look at your power bill, it’s going through the roof.

“This whole renewable issue, making power going to be free! It’s never been dearer before in our lives. You are the government!”

The pair continued to argue over which options were cheaper before Plibersek brought up the consequences of Joyce’s leadership.

“Barnaby, coal-fired power plants shut under you,” she pointed out.

“What did you do to stop it?”

Plibersek’s grilling on the cost of energy under the Albanese government comes as the chief executive of Alinta Energy, Jeff Dimery, said Australians should brace themselves for at least a 35 per cent rise in their energy bills. 

“When we run our modelling for energy pricing next year, using the current market prices, tariffs are going up a minimum 35 per cent,” Dimery said at the Australian Financial Review’s energy and climate summit.

As reported by the Financial Review, Dimery expressed concerns about the country’s transition to clean energy.

“I’m sure I’m not the only one just observing the gap that’s really opening up between the certainty of what’s coming out and the uncertainty of what’s replacing it and going in,” he said.

“I personally don’t believe we can achieve the transition based on what we’re seeing to date that is going to be delivered; I think we’re headed for failure unless things change significantly.”

However, the Climate Council’s energy expert and former President of BP Australiasia, Greg Bourne, said the switch to renewables is the next necessary step.

“Coal is not a commercially viable industry any longer,” he said in a statement.

“Coal is unable to compete on cost with renewable energy, it is also inflexible, ageing, unreliable and inefficient.

“In Australia, and globally, renewables backed by storage deliver the cheapest power, and do so without the greenhouse emissions coal and gas produce.”

The merits of renewable energy compared to fossil fuel aside, the rising cost of energy bills will no doubt be of concern among seniors after recent data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) indicated that older Australians are already suffering the most from the rising cost of living with pensioners experiencing an annual household living cost of 4.9 per cent.

Head of Prices Statistics at the ABS Michelle Marquardt said the main culprit affecting older Australians is the increase in grocery prices, but household costs also played a large role.

“These households were also more affected by increases in housing costs, as they have relatively higher expenditure levels on utilities, maintenance and repair, and property rates,” Marquardt said.

Stories that matter
Emails delivered daily
Sign up