Controversial obstetrician asks, do we need midwives? 165



View Profile

First it was fathers, then it was doctors and now some want midwives to get out of the delivery room.

One of the world’s oldest professions has come in to question by one of the world’s leading obstetricians, Michel Odent.

In an interview with the NZ Herald, Dr Odent talked about his new book ‘Do We Need Midwives’, which is about how detrimental modern midwives have become to the birthing process.

This is an incredibly controversial view considering many of us know, or even were, a midwife. It’s a beloved profession with many mothers preferring to have a doula or midwife at the business end than a male doctor.

The 84-year-old London-based Frenchman said that woman are losing the ability to give birth unaided and draws on his experience as the head of a Paris maternity unit.

Dr Odent is in fact a promoter of water births and breast feeding, however when it comes to midwives, he believes their making it harder for women to give birth, by doing the work.

He made headlines years ago by suggesting fathers should not to be present at births (they disturb the focus and emotional equilibrium the mother needs, he argues) and that women should not be given drugs.

But, before we dismiss him as out of touch, Michel provocatively says, “When I ask ‘Do we need midwives?’, it is a real question,” he says. “If all births are medicalised, what sort of a midwife will we need?”

Ideally, women would give birth in a dark, warm room with just a midwife. The process would be calm and relaxing, unlike the frantic scene we’ve come to know in a bright, hectic labour ward.

We are undermining a natural process, says Dr Odent, and as a result there are too many Caesarians i.e. a “neutralisation of natural selection”.

As brash as that sounds, he continued and explains, “I am not against Caesarians. I have performed over 1,000 of them. But I am taking a long-term view of how increased medicalisation will affect humankind, and the rational result is that some day the most common way for humans to be born will be by Caesarian. We need to look ahead and understand the consequences”.

“In previous centuries, women who were capable of giving birth had lots of children. Women who weren’t died in labour,” he continued.

“Thanks to the miracles of modern medicine and reproductive science, most women who want two babies can have them. Similarly, women who once might have had a great many babies can now stop at two; this is wonderful for the women concerned but it logically has an overall impact”.


It’s a lot to take in and think about, so does he have a point? Should midwives only exist in optimal settings? What was your birth/s like?

Starts at 60 Writers

The Starts at 60 writers team seek out interesting topics and write them especially for you.

  1. Each birth is different, each mother is different.. I don’t think anyone be it a doctor or a midwife or any other so called expert, can pontificate that their way is the right way..

  2. I had Caesareans for all my kids glad I did and do not believe that it effected me or them in any way. I could not have natural births and I was glad not too. I also believe it should be up to the person having the baby which way she wants to go. I also believe she has the decision to decide who is with her when she has the child. Why (other than history) does a women have to give birth the natural way why does she and the baby have to go through that when she can have a caesarean birth…….

    6 REPLY
    • One of my daughters had all Caesareans too. I went into labour with my twins and am so glad I did not have natural.

    • Well Judith Forbes normal birth is the way it’s meant to be and C/sections are used only if necessary.There is nothing more empowering and beautiful for women who are able to give birth normally.C/ section is surgery with associated risks and as a midwife I have witnessed those risks.

    • Who says so….I am saying that women need to be empowered and be allowed to do it the way they wish….with out them there would be no kids?,!!!!

  3. I’m glad the Midwife was
    There !!! Two of my babies where delivered by Midwife Because so called Doctor was on Holiday second one just didn’t turn up !

    1 REPLY
  4. this has long been the thinking of many obstetricians ..they have a vested interest …,,just stops them feeling like God ..and continuing the BS..i had 2 Caesareans .not by choice , and was fairly well butchered by an incompetent obstetrician .

  5. When he has spent 12-24 hrs with something the size of a pumpkin trying to be passed by him I might, just might, think about what he had to say.

  6. It is a matter of choice but if there are medical complications I think your far smarter to be in a hospital

  7. He is 84 years old and like many older people changed his mind over his life time! Birth of a baby is a very individual process and it should be left to the mother to decide which way she wants to go and who is in the room with her, unless it is a medical emergency!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *