When Divorce forces a friendship reckoning

It’s one of the cruellest truths about divorce – when a marriage ends, friendships often become collateral damage.

You’re 62, in the early stages of a messy separation, and already the ripple effects are spreading far beyond lawyers and living arrangements. Your ex-wife has drawn a line in the sand and told your mutual friends they must choose between you. And, painfully, some of them are actually doing it.

What does that say about her? About them? And perhaps, even more uncomfortably, what might it say about you?

Let’s start with the obvious: divorce at any age is hard, but divorce later in life can feel like an earthquake that shakes the ground under decades of shared social life. You’ve probably known some of these friends for twenty, thirty, maybe even forty years. You’ve been to their kids’ weddings, celebrated milestones together, gone on holidays. You might have thought that friendship was built on something stronger than who you happen to be married to.

So when people start choosing sides, it feels like betrayal – twice over. First from your ex-partner, who has weaponised loyalty, and then from the friends who seem to have abandoned you.

The loyalty trap

When a marriage breaks down, some people – like your ex-wife – feel the need to reclaim control. Divorce can be humiliating, frightening, and deeply destabilising. It strips away the sense of identity that comes with being one half of a couple. So what does she do? She tries to reassert her power, to draw boundaries that make her feel safe.

Telling friends to “choose” is a way of controlling the chaos. It’s not fair, it’s not mature, and it’s not kind – but it is, sadly, very human. It’s fear masquerading as strength.

That doesn’t excuse the behaviour, of course. It’s manipulative. It puts mutual friends in an impossible position. And it speaks to a person’s inability to tolerate ambiguity – the fact that both of you can be decent people going through an ugly situation, and that it’s possible to care about both without betraying either.

The friends who choose

And then there are the friends. Their choices sting the most. You may feel angry or blindsided – wondering if the laughter, loyalty and late-night talks were ever real.

But here’s the hard truth: many people simply can’t handle the emotional complexity that comes with staying friends with both parties. They fear getting caught in the middle, or being seen as disloyal. Sometimes they think choosing one side will make things neater. And sometimes, the choice has nothing to do with morality or fairness – just convenience.

It’s often the case that one person in a couple was more socially dominant – the organiser of dinners, the communicator, the one who kept the group together. If that person was your ex-wife, then some of those friends may have drifted toward her simply because she’s the social glue.

Others might quietly sympathise with you but choose not to show it, out of fear of her reaction. Social circles can be surprisingly fragile ecosystems, and people like to keep the peace – even if it means sacrificing someone else’s feelings.

What it says about you

Now, this might sound harsh, but it’s worth sitting with: how are you showing up in this moment? Are you bitter and angry, venting to mutual friends about how unfair she’s being? Are you trying to rally allies, even unconsciously? Because people do pick up on energy – and if they sense a tug-of-war, they’ll often retreat altogether.

This isn’t about taking blame. It’s about recognising that after a long marriage, everyone around you is adjusting to a new normal. You’re learning who your friends truly are, but you’re also learning who you are without her. That can be both painful and liberating.

The friends who choose her were never truly your friends alone. They belonged to the couple you once were. That version of friendship can’t survive unchanged when the couple dissolves. But that doesn’t mean your social world has to collapse – only that it will evolve.

Rebuilding after rupture

So what can you do? First, resist the urge to play the same game. Don’t ask anyone to choose. Don’t try to correct the record or “win” people back. Time and dignity are your best allies. The friends who matter – the ones who genuinely care about you – will eventually make their way back when the dust settles.

In the meantime, this is your opportunity to build a new circle. Seek out people who know you as an individual, not as one half of a marriage. Join a club, volunteer, take a class, reconnect with old mates who may have drifted away. It’s astonishing how much space opens up when the drama of divorce stops dominating your social calendar.

And as for your ex-wife – she’s doing what she needs to feel in control. Let her. You don’t have to participate. In time, people will see the difference between someone who heals quietly and someone who needs to dictate the terms of everyone else’s loyalty.

One day, when you look back, you might see this painful moment not as a loss, but as a kind of social sorting – a clearing-out of relationships that were tied to an old identity. You’ll see who had the courage to hold steady, and you’ll understand that some friendships were never really yours to keep.

So, what does it say about your wife and your friends? It says they’re human – flawed, frightened, perhaps a bit selfish. But what happens next will say far more about you: that you took the high road, rebuilt your life with grace, and proved that loyalty can’t be demanded – it has to be earned.

More Bess Strachan columns you may like:

My step-daughters treat me like an outsider. Should I give them space?