Older people need care now: why must the safeguard wait until January?

Oct 27, 2026
Share:
Share via emailShare on Facebook
Waiting alone: Older Australians need support to stay at home while families await changes to the aged-care assessment system. AI-generated illustration. Image: SA60

COMMENT

If your mother needs help getting out of bed tomorrow morning, a government promise about January offers very little comfort.

That is what I keep coming back to after the Commonwealth Ombudsman’s damning investigation into Australia’s aged-care assessment system.

Behind the arguments about algorithms are older Australians trying to get enough support to keep living at home. When that support falls short, families may find themselves filling the gap, sometimes while struggling to manage their own health or hold down a job.

The Ombudsman has raised serious concerns about a system in which assessors cannot override automated outcomes, even when they consider them clinically inappropriate. The department disputes aspects of the findings.

There is an important distinction here. The investigation did not establish that the algorithm’s results were clinically wrong, but surely we should expect a workable safeguard when a qualified professional believes an outcome does not reflect someone’s needs.

The government says it has heard the concerns. Parliament has passed an escalation pathway allowing a person to review and, where necessary, change an outcome when an assessment has not fully captured someone’s circumstances.

It starts in January, an independent review is also due to report in the first half of 2027.

My question is: what happens between now and then?

We are heading towards Christmas. A daughter worried about her father falling in the shower needs to know what help she can get before the holidays and she should not have to spend those weeks trying to work out which part of the system might listen.

I accept that changing legislation and preparing staff can take time. I want the government to explain why January is the earliest this pathway can operate, and what arrangements will protect people in the meantime, especially when it’s been a major problem for so long already.

Who can urgently reconsider a disputed outcome today? What happens when an assessor flags a serious concern and how quickly can a family expect an answer?

Those are reasonable questions for a government asking Australians to have confidence in its reforms.

If the permanent safeguard cannot be ready before Christmas, tell families what you will put in place now. Make the instructions clear enough for an exhausted carer to follow.

Older Australians should be able to trust that someone with the authority to help will listen when an assessment appears to have missed something important.

Their need for care will not wait until January.

Read the ABC investigation here and Commonwealth Ombudsman Report here 

Comments 15

Join the conversation. Comments are reviewed before they appear.

  1. Josephine M. 27 Oct 2026

    AI is poison to Society as a whole, using it for the elderly is a crime CRIME!!. Todays society keep telling us pensioners that we simply sailed through life, without any hard times, going without and not a problem to be had, simply sailed through having fun. If that was the case we would not urgently need help from the government, who never provided us with work from home, money for child care, money for this money for that..we had to do everything without help, no holidays overseas every year no new cars every 5 years etc, etc, etc it just goes on...THAT IS WHY WE ARE PENSIONERS!!We had to watch every penny to make sure the house payment was there, we could not afford after school activities and other enticing things todays children have to use and amuse themselves today. We deserve help, we have worked hard to get what little we have please do not deny us.

    1. Natalie L. 27 Oct 2026

      So true. The old system where one could get intouch with a local Provider, one that a Friend or Family know about, get an assessment, get the help needed by Trained Staff is long gone. Staff not trained, untidy dress code and no personal contact with the assessed, who should be an RN.

  2. Michael F. 27 Oct 2026

    I am waiting for a watch with a fall detector it was requested January 26 and was told that they tried to phone me once so didn’t bother again, go figure?

  3. Paul J. 27 Oct 2026

    I empathise with older Australians waiting for home care packages. I’m a Boomer and my time is coming. But we as Australians should be asking why all of us haven’t been considering what is happening, and what is going to happen, when the number of older Australians really becomes unmanageable. When the census numbers for many years have been alerting all of us about this. Why, as a nation, aren’t we ready? It has been so obvious for a long time. If governments try to handle this year by year we haven’t a hope of being ready. It needs a multi term solution and most governments don’t look that far in advance. Then there’s the question of who will staff the positions needed? The system is heavily dependent on migration. Hello!! Everyone seems to be calling for cuts there! Those already working in this sector are getting nervous. I know. I talk to a number of them who are caring for my father. They are only too aware of the conversation about them and their status. If some of the already working in the sector leave, the problem will go beyond critical. If current Australians don’t want these jobs, we had better be prepared to look after our own family members. Is there any other solution out there? 🙏🏼

  4. Sandra W. 27 Oct 2026

    I was already receiving some support at home, after having breast cancer treatment. 2 hours a week. I June 26, I fell in the shower and fractured my back, between the 11th & 12th vertebrae.
    This was very painful. I asked aged care for a new assessment and was told 12 weeks.
    I rang the office of our local parliamentary member, and the process was only a few weeks.
    We should not have to do this to obtain extra help.
    I was also told by the person who came to reassess me, that he had to learn what to write, due to the A1 doing the assessment, so I did not miss out.
    This is so wrong. Aged Care can be a very necessary part of our lives.

  5. Julie C. 27 Oct 2026

    Older Australians have been waiting decades for proper care. The trouble is the politicians know that family will care when they won't. As one politician put it a while ago, " you do for family". Letting family care for the elderly is soooo much cheaper, Considering the pittance they pay to carers.

  6. Julie P. 27 Oct 2026

    It’s not just the assessment process that needs to be changed. Even when you have an approval for funding it’s up to My Aged Care when they will release those funds to the package provider for desperately needed assistive technology and support. Release of funds depends on the priority allocated to the assessment - standard, medium or high and this is allocated by the algorithm. I recently had an assessment review and whilst the original assessment had a priority of medium, the new one has a priority of standard even though it’s a month later than the original one. Surely the priority should now be high and the money will be allocated when MAC have time. NOT GOOD ENOUGH. IT WILL HAVE TAKEN 2 MONTHS + for me to get the support I needed two months ago.

  7. Ruth F. 27 Oct 2026

    Still waiting for funding - assisted technology and home improvements. We reveived a phone call 3 days after an age care assessment was completed to say the funding has been approved . That was July and still no word. My husband's condition has deteriorated and his mobility on a wheelie walker has declined. I assist him with showers and dressing. Wheel chairs and chairs and ramps would help. Have been to every specialist but still no answers why be has neuropathy . No feeling in feet or legs and cannot stand or walk un assisted. He is 80 years old and was a fit healthy until about 12 to 18 months ago. No faith in the medical profession.

  8. Astrid S. 27 Oct 2026

    I am a fall risk. I’ve been waiting soooo long for shower rails in my small shower. Also same waiting for a fall pendant. My carer went on a 4 day break. What if i had a fall in shower? Can’t take my mobile in the shower, i would’ve been cold, hurt n wet for 4 days on the floor. I’m 72 nearly 73, would I have made it?

  9. Wendy R. 28 Oct 2026

    i could not agree more to the sentiment that older people need the changes now! Unfortunately my experience of 30+ years in the sector, tells me that the wheels of bureaucracy and government grind very slowly indeed. I say that calmly, but I am not calm about the delay very frail older people must endure and sometimes die enduring. It is not that DOHDA and Government are only now becoming aware that SAH including the algorithm is not fit for purpose, they have spent very valuable life saving time pushing back on any criticism of the program, instead of embracing legitimate concerns, so in terms of action they are now starting from scratch!

  10. Vivienne B. 28 Oct 2026

    The 'system' was a mess even before the new AI version. My husband died of cancer 2 years ago while waiting for assistance. I was contacted re an assessment visit an hour after I was told of his death. (His oncologist and our GP had both tried to speed up the process.) No doubt our living in the country contributed to the snail's pace of the action, and nothing now surprises me about our care provisions.

  11. Ruth D. 28 Oct 2026

    I was on a Package 3 before Nov 1st 2025. In April 2026 I was granted an upgrade to a Package 7 on the new system. It is now nearly November and I am still waiting for that upgrade to happen - and have been told I might get it by the end of the year. Meanwhile, I am running out of money to keep the assistance I am now getting, without any upgrade to the new package.
    I think this is disgraceful.
    I am 90 years of age, living by myself.

  12. Joy H. 28 Oct 2026

    Yes, I applied 4 years ago, because I had Rhematoid Arthritis, and critical respiratory issues, for home support. After 2 assessments, my paperwork

  13. Joy H. 28 Oct 2026

    I applied for home support 4 years ago, suffering from Rhemutoid Arthritis and serious respiratory issues. After 2 assessments, during 1970, my paperwork got lost in the system.
    I tried again in June this year, assessed for home support, successful, but funding will not be available for 6-8 months. Now my partner suffers from blackouts, and was on crutches during my assessment, Aged care STILL unable to assist. Well Mr Chalmers, we know how the Budget for Aged Care came out UNDER BUDGET, all talk, NO ACTION. wait till your parents need it

  14. Julie P. 6 Nov 2026

    I had an AT & HM ASSESSMENT COMPLETED IN September 2026 with an approved level of medium and priority of medium which did not provide sufficient funds to purchase my chair. I requested a review which was completed 6/10/26 and approved 12/10/26 at a level of high but with a priority of standard. I now have sufficient funding to purchase the chair but My Aged Care will not release the money because of the priority. I have a chair waiting at the suppliers but no way to pay for it until the money is released to my service provider. I can’t even pay for the chair and be reimbursed until the service provider actually receives the funding into my account even though they have the letter approving the funding. Reason given - “ Unfortunately, we cannot reimburse funds to you if you purchase the chair privately before the AT funds are issued. We will be unable to claim those funds back from Services Australia at the end of the quarter, meaning we cannot reimburse you for any funds spent privately.” If the funds were there I wouldn’t need to pay and be reimbursed. I’m worried the supplier won’t keep the chair and I’ll have to start the process all over again. The system is broken, very difficult to navigate and non transparent. I can’t even get a 2 in 1 (screen and door combined) front door even though it’s a safety issue in entering our home.