Something astonishing has turned up: your late fifties are not the beginning of the end, but quite possibly the apex.
A new study in Intelligence by University of Western Australia researcher Dr Gilles Gignac and co-authors has gone and quantified what many of us have had a hunch about: that middle age – say 55-60 years old – is when the mind, or at least the “cognitive-personality functioning index” (CPFI), peaks.
What They Did
The researchers constructed what they call the Cognitive-Personality Functioning Index (CPFI), combining measures of intelligence (both fluid and crystallised), judgment, personality traits (such as conscientiousness, emotional stability), and other facets of mental life.
They drew on decades of psychological research, large sample data, to track how different mental and personality attributes evolve over a lifetime.
What They Found (and What It Means)
It’s not what you grew up hearing (that your twenties are your prime, that thirty, forty, even fifty are just decline).
The CPFI shows:
Fluid intelligence – the kind that lets you solve novel problems, think fast, hold memory spans, shift between tasks – tends to peak in early adulthood (20s) and then declines.
Crystallised intelligence – the kind built up over years: knowledge, vocabulary, experience, the capacity to draw on what you’ve been through – increases for decades, so your store of wisdom keeps growing.
Personality traits that help enormously in life’s messy business – conscientiousness, emotional stability – tend to improve across adulthood and level off later, rather than collapse.
Also: moral reasoning, avoidance of sunk-cost fallacies (i.e. “oh, I’ve come this far so I must see it through”) sharpen with life experience. You get better at seeing what’s worth pushing, what’s not.
On the flip side:
Cognitive flexibility (switching between tasks, adapting strategies) declines,
Cognitive empathy (guessing what others are thinking) also wanes somewhat,
The urge to dive into abstract puzzles (the “need for cognition”) tends to decrease.
But – and this is the headline – the gains (in wisdom, experience, emotional stability, judgement) more than compensate for the losses (in speed, flexibility, novelty-seeking) at roughly 55-60. That’s where the CPFI reaches its summit.
Why It’s Good News for Those of Us “Over 50”
If you’re in your late 50s, this study offers a kind of redemption narrative:
Those nagging aches and the slowing down? Losing some quickness is real. But your experienced mind, your ability to judge, to resist bad decisions, to act with steadiness? Those are strongest now.
It suggests that this stretch of life is less about decline and more about synthesis – all your earlier learning, all your failures, all your accumulated know-how, stitched together into something potent.
It also re-frames how we think about “peak” in business, politics, creativity: maybe we’ve undervalued the older bracket. The cast of public figures past 60 might seem spent, but maybe they are also beyond their best functional mix (speed plus depth plus stability).
Some Caveats and What We Don’t Know
This is based on averages. Not everybody gets the same profile. Some people retain more flexibility, some more speed, some more empathy. Life experience, health, education, opportunities matter.
Also, measuring personality traits, intelligence, and judgment is tricky. There’s always measurement error, cohort effects (people born in different decades have different experiences), and lifestyle variables.
And while 55-60 looks like the sweet spot for CPFI, what happens afterward? The decline is gradual, but real in many components. So it doesn’t mean immortality in the mind.
The Verdict
If you’re 55, 58, or 60 – congratulations. According to Gignac et al., you are (on average) running at max cognitive plus personality potential. Your knowledge, your steadiness, your wisdom, your emotional equilibrium are giving you more than you might feel when comparing yourself to the twenty-something who can outrun you or type three emails at once.
For Starts at 60, here’s what I’d say: this is not consolation for what’s past. It’s recognition of what is. You’re not fading. You’re peaking.
Proudly Australian owned and operated