Would you eat it? Mum sparks debate over whether food left out is safe to eat

Nov 20, 2020
The woman left the cooked lasagne out overnight. Source: Getty.

How long can you leave cooked food out? That’s the question on everyone’s lips after one mum sparked a heated debate online after she revealed she left her cooked lasagne out overnight and then placed it the fridge the next morning. Taking to the popular Facebook group Mums Who Cook and Bake on Friday, the mum questioned whether it was still okay to eat or whether she should just bin it.

“So I made a lasagne last night around 10, was [too] hot to put in fridge!” she explained. “I forgot til [sic] 4am, will it be okay to eat? It’s in fridge now.”

The post attracted a slew of different responses from the group’s other members, with some saying it’s fine to eat while others said it’s a big no-no.

“My Greek parents and grandparents always left things out on the stove overnight and even all day!” one commenter wrote. “We never got sick. I think you would be fine.”

Another said while they reckon it’ll be safe to eat, it’s best to go with your gut, writing: “I would still eat it. But if [you’re] worried go with your gut.” And a third wrote: “I would eat it. They didn’t have fridges back in the day and they all survived.”

One commenter wrote they always leave cooked dishes in the oven overnight and refrigerate the next morning, writing: “Some days we leave lasagne, Mac and cheese (with sausages and bacon and ham), potato bake those type of bakes in the oven overnight after a big BBQ and fridge it next morning. All good.”

Meanwhile, one group member said they wouldn’t risk it, writing: “I have done this so many times. I tend to turf it.” Another agreed, saying food poisoning is not pleasant, commenting: “That’s a no from me, food poisoning is not pleasant.”

According to Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ), cooked food should be eaten or refrigerated within two hours.

“Food which has been kept in the Temperature Danger Zone (between 5 – 60 degrees Celsius) for between two and four hours cannot be put back in the refrigerator and must be consumed,” the government agency explained. “Any food which remains in the Temperature Danger Zone for four or more hours must be discarded.”

The good news is, you can also freeze cooked food — if you get onto it within the first two hours, that is. According to Food Safety Australia, leftovers containing cooked meat or poultry can be kept frozen for two to six months, pizza for one to two months, while chicken nuggets and burger patties should be consumed within three months. Soups and stews can be frozen for two to three months.

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Pinterest

Sue's sassy!

She became a member of Starts at 60 and got access to amazing travel deals, free masterclasses, exclusive news and features and hot member discounts!

And she entered to win a $10K trip for four people to Norfolk Island in 2021. Join now, it’s free to become a member. Members get more.


What are your thoughts on this? Would you still eat it?

Please sign in to post a comment.
Retrieving conversation…
Stories that matter
Emails delivered daily
Sign up