New Zealand democracy in crisis, or steady as she goes?

Nov 21, 2026
Share:
Share via emailShare on Facebook
Many Kiwis hold concerns for their electoral system in the wake of the November 7 election. Photo: Ben McKay/AAP

By Ben McKay in Hobart

Claims of voter suppression and electoral system rorting have clouded the New Zealand election in the two weeks since preliminary results were announced.

The electoral system at the heart of New Zealand’s current political ructions was only introduced after a series of miscalculations.

In 1987, after a Royal Commission recommended change, Prime Minister David Lange promised during a televised debate he would hold a referendum on a new electoral model.

This wasn’t party policy – with accounts differing on whether he mis-read his notes or was poorly advised – and Labour backtracked on the pledge in office.

Then in 1990, National Prime Minister Jim Bolger campaigned – and won – on righting that broken promise, even though that too infuriated many in his party.

The National and Labour governments had led alternating, majority governments for six decades in a two-party stranglehold that the blunt first-past-the-post system created.

Mr Bolger had hoped Kiwis would reject the switch.

Instead, in 1992 at an informal vote, in 1993 at a binding referendum, and in 2011 when another national poll offered the chance to reverse course, Kiwis embraced their mixed-member proportional (MMP) system.

In 30 years of use, it has transferred power from major to minor parties, produced a wider representation of MPs, and enabled an era of deal-making and coalition-building.

Smaller parties have flourished, with Winston Peters’ populist NZ First party, free-marketers ACT, left-wingers the Greens and indigenous-focused Maori Party all now bedded into the system.

At this election, climate-concerned centrists Opportunity joined them in parliament.

New Zealanders are still waiting to learn which parties will form the next government, after preliminary results from the November 7 election showed an inconclusive result.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon’s coalition currently has a two-seat majority, but with hundreds of thousands of votes yet to be added, that could change, with an advantage resting on a quirk of MMP: the “overhang”.

Under the system, New Zealanders get two votes: one for a local electorate MP and one for a party, which is supposed to determine its share of MPs in parliament.

An overhang occurs when a party wins more electorate seats than its nationwide party vote entitles it to.

In 2026, this happened to a major party, Luxon’s National, for the first time.

On its party vote, National should have won 36 MPs but will end up with 42 after a strong showing in electorates.

The Maori Party will also benefit from an overhang, given it won five electorate seats with a nationwide party vote of just 0.6 per cent.

Both the left – through the Maori Party – and the right – through the ACT, NZ First and wealthy right-wing backers – ran campaigns urging Kiwis to split their vote, which created such an outcome.

In such a tight election, when the final margin between the right and left blocs could be one MP or even deadlock, this quirk – not the overall vote count – could prove the difference.

Accordingly, 46 academics and experts were galvanised to pen an open letter this week, calling for reforms before the distortion is incentivised and baked in.

Led by former prime minister Geoffrey Palmer, they want to “keep the P in MMP” and confirm the nationwide party vote as the deciding factor in parliament’s proportions.

“The 2026 election has exposed a significant weakness … a breakdown, both accidental and deliberately engineered, in the purpose of the party and electorate votes that we have not seen in the 30 years New Zealand has had MMP,” the letter reads.

University of Otago professor Andrew Geddis warned future elections could instead be an “arms race” of sophisticated strategic voting campaigns.

Labour and the Greens have indicated the same view.

The right has not, with senior National MP Mark Mitchell telling Newstalk ZB such concerns were “hysteria and hand-wringing”, and ACT leader David Seymour downplaying the issue.

“Voters are entitled to use their two votes however they choose and political parties should respect their decisions,” he said.

It remains to be seen whether the right might change their views on the release of the final results, expected on November 27.

Unlike in Australia, where the electoral commission drip-feeds any outstanding ballot counting in the days after election night, this is done en masse 20 days later in New Zealand.

The NZ electoral commission is using that time to re-count existing ballots and plug in the remaining 400,000 votes – or 16 per cent of all votes cast – including overseas, out-of-electorate and speciality ballots.

Should any electorates remain too close to call – including Hamilton East and Wairarapa, with preliminary margins under 500 votes – the election result could yet be deferred again for recounts.

A further issue from the left has been levied at the government’s pre-election reforms targeting enrolment.

The right to vote was stripped from prisoners, disenfranchising a few thousand people, while the enrolment deadline was brought forward two weeks, from election day to before the advance voting period began.

While it’s unclear how many people this caught out, public sector advice to government was that the changes brought the “most disenfranchisement voters have had in 30 years” with “younger and rural Maori likely to be most impacted”.

The government maintained it needed to act as the electoral commission was unable to cope with reams of election-day enrolments and special votes that slowed its counting.

Luxon also defended the move by funding a bigger marketing campaign to advise of the changes, saying by naming an election day in January he had “given plenty of time”.

Others contend this was a strategy by a right-wing government to have fewer people voting from groups that tended to favour parties of the left.

University of Canterbury professor Bronwyn Hayward and Victoria University of Wellington associate professor Lara Greaves said the changes amounted to voter suppression.

Greens co-leader Chloe Swarbrick agreed.

“We also know these changes have had a greater impact on those who are already disenfranchised such as young people, first-time voters, Maori, Pasifika and those without fixed addresses,” Ms Swabrick told AAP.

“New Zealanders should be concerned by these changes and the tampering with our democracy.”

Professor Hayward said irrespective of the election result, the electoral system needed to be safeguarded.

“Addressing the overhang is complicated, but not a crisis,” Prof Hayward told AAP.

“There needs to be a cross-party agreement taking in registration changes and MMP changes. It shouldn’t be done by the government of the day.”

Comments 0

Join the conversation. Comments are reviewed before they appear.

Be the first to comment.