Outrage over confronting photo of elderly woman ‘forced to stand on train’

Australians were shocked to see a photo of an elderly woman standing in a train while young commuters occupy the seats. Source: Getty

A confronting photo of an elderly woman clinging to a pole in a train to stabilise herself has sparked controversy across the country, as many question whether the younger generation has lost respect for the elderly.

Despite there being a rule on public transport across the world for younger commuters to give up their seats for the elderly, pregnant women and those with a physical disability, it appears the guidelines were ignored on this particular train.

In the photo, shared on Facebook group Aussie Aussie Aussie Aussie late last week, the woman can be seen bent over, clutching to the pole in the middle of the train while young commuters take prime position in seats along the side, all wearing headphones. It is simply captioned: “No respect.”

It’s not clear when exactly the photo was taken, but it has gone viral after being re-shared over the last few days.

Australians have been left outraged after seeing a photo online of an elderly woman standing up in a train while young people occupy the seats. Source: Facebook/ Aussie Aussie Aussie Aussie

In a matter of days, the post has been shared over 23,000 times with thousands more debating over why the woman was left standing and whether or not anybody nearby offered her a seat.

A vast majority were shocked by the photograph, claiming they would always give up their seat for those that needed it most.

“I just want to yank off their head phones, tell them to look around and say that could be your mother one day,” one disgruntled person commented.

Another added: “I’m 20 and I can’t believe this. None of them would’ve heard if she’d asked politely for the seat – all three seated with their earphone in or headphones on! Where’s the human connection?”

A third said: “No respect what so ever. Gone are the days where the younger generation look after their elders”.

However, others took a different approach to the photograph, claiming there are two sides to every story and questioning if the person who took the photo didn’t lend a helping hand.

Some even brought up the point that the young commuters may have offered the seat and the elderly woman could have denied.

“Not defending them but someone may have offered, but the elderly said, ‘no it’s okay, I’m getting off soon or at the next stop. I offer all the time and on a few occasions this has happened to me, we’re they’d be polite and say, ‘thanks but no thanks’,” one person wrote.

“And who took the photo instead of saying something?” a second questioned.

Another said: “So quick to judge, but no one knows the story behind the picture. A whole train full of people and not one person offered a seat. Unlikely.”

In a statement to the Mail Online, Sydney Trains said: “Sydney Trains encourages all of its passengers to observe appropriate transport etiquette including respecting elderly, disabled or pregnant customers by offering up their seats.”

What are your thoughts on this photograph? Have you ever seen something like this happen? Do you think young people have lost respect for their elders?

Share via emailShare on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Pinterest

Leave your comment

Please sign in to post a comment.
Retrieving conversation…
Stories that matter
Emails delivered daily
Sign up