One of the great mysteries of American history – the Salem witch trials

When the Massachusetts Criminal Code was drafted in 1641, it contained the following capital crimes, in order: Idolatry Witchcraft (“…if

the-witches-stacy-schiff-coverWhen the Massachusetts Criminal Code was drafted in 1641, it contained the following capital crimes, in order:

  • Idolatry
  • Witchcraft (“…if any man or woman be a witch; is, has or consults with a familiar spirit, they shall be put to death…”)
  • Blasphemy
  • Murder
  • Poisoning
  • Bestiality

That order explains in part (along with the mores of the time) the dreadful happenings in Salem in the year 1692.

Much has been written about it before, but Stacy Schiff’s The Witches, newly released by Hachette, must now be considered the seminal work on the subject. Written following years of research, (the last 60+ pages are notes, references and bibliography), the book orders the dark happenings of Salem’s witchcraft trials, puts them into perspective, corrects much prior misunderstanding.

Although a serious historical document, it reads as a thriller.

Schiff describes how New Englanders in the especially cruel winter of 1691/92 lived in the dark in both a metaphorical and a literal sense: “…the sky was crow black, pitch black, so black that it could be difficult to keep to a path, so black that a line of trees might freely migrate to another location… you might find yourself pursued by a rabid black hog… left bloodied and disoriented.”

The Puritanical background of this New England enclave provided a narrow and dour understanding of Biblical text. Everything that happened in their everyday lives devolved upon a passage of scripture, although the application may have been somewhat different to the way we now consider it. If a killer cat flew in at night, took hold of your throat and crushed your chest, it could be scared away by invoking the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost; in the meantime, you might conclude it to have been an irascible neighbour who paid you a visit in feline form. That being so, you would report them and, dependent on others supporting your case, have them charged as a witch.

The fear and suspicion of others created and advanced the spectre of witchcraft. A child might indict a parent, a grandmother a grandchild, a servant their master, a neighbour his fellow, even siblings might turn against each other. A form of mass hysteria seemed to abound in which, once an individual was accused, other voices would be raised in affirmation. It was all heresy and hearsay but, when enough ‘evidence’ had been produced, a guilty verdict became almost inevitable. A total of fourteen women and five men were convicted of witchcraft and put to death. And nor was it limited to humans: Two dogs were among those executed!

An almost mesmeric effect overtook many accused. Some came to the belief that they were, indeed witches, even spoke of seven flying through the night sky on two sticks and flying so fast they had no idea whether they flew through or above the trees. One witch spoke of three flying on a stick that broke under their weight but they all managed to cling to the remaining half and continued their flight.

It would be easy to think that in our modern, enlightened society matters such as these would soon be put to rights; in today’s court of law, a modern solicitor would quickly overturn such circumstantial evidence – effectively little more than tittle-tattle arising from a form of mass hysteria – and achieve an acquittal. Several times while reading The Witches, I had to remind myself that lawmakers at the time believed themselves rational and progressive, as was the law they drafted. The law of the time was simply what the law of the time was…

My thanks to Hachette Australia for my ARC of this brilliant and eminently readable book.

The Witches by Stacy Schiff is available now from Dymocks
Enter the promo Code START60FREE at checkout for free regular shipping, Australia-wide!Dymocks Click here

Join the Starts at 60 Book Club for more great reading recommendations!

Dymocks Book Bloggers

  1. Christianity at it worst, 2 young girls aged 9 and 11 years old were the first to be accused, later a 4 year old girl was accused, but it was mainly women they accused , those accused were stripped and examined for any marks, small freckles or scar immediately told them that you were a witch. They were tortured and sent to trial and executed. Christianity has a dark history when you explore back into it

  2. This would be very interesting to read. The Psychology behind it is fascinating.

    • Highly recommended, Debbie. As I mentioned in the review, brilliant and eminently readable.

  3. Cheryl Jackson  

    If you can find it, The Royal Shakespeare’s production of “the Crucible” is an amazing insight into the hysteria provoked by so called Christians. The full movie is about 3 and a half hours long but so intense you don’t notice the time passing. I saw it at the movies with only one intermission. Best movie in a long, long time.

  4. I thought it had been worked out the irrational behaviour of the ‘witches’ was most likely caused by the hallucinogenic effect of ergot poisoning from contaminated rye. The puritanical Christians believed every behaviour was from God or the Devil. Science allows us to understand what back then must have been a strange terrifying thing, to have once sane normal neighbours lose the plot. Too animals ate the contaminated grain so even reliable old Dobbin would have been cursed by a witch when he overturned the buggy in terror at a hallucination.

    • Yes Barbara,Ergot was the culprit and I think women suffered for centuries later from that condemnation of being witches. Even into this century those who hold so called “pagan” beliefs,get called witches.

  5. a case of just too much time on their hands …or as my dear ole Irish Ma would say ( she had a quote for every situation ) ‘the devil makes work for idle hands ‘….

  6. They were really stupid back then, religion hasnt changed all that much,,, they still hurt people and use Gods name as a reason!!!!!quite dumb really…..

  7. This is a fascinating story and the town of Salem has turned it into a tourist attraction. It was moving to see Giles Corey’s grave. Ever since reading ‘The Crucible’ I’ve been interested in the story and I believe we see hysterical mass responses to events with people people being labelled unfairly today.

    • Karen O'Brien-Hall  

      The Crucible is one of my favourite plays and when directing it I found the stories of Salem so intriguing. The play, of course, was written as a metaphor for McCarthyism, yet without these overtones, it has such strength. Like others, I;m lookinf forward to reading this one. Thanks for your review John.

  8. marlene Sanders  

    this book is right in line with my rant today. people tend to forget that there were/are extremists in any religion and they do not want to explore too far in case they find facts. Very good review John!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *